4 items
Every essay mourning AI's death of human consultation is describing the product the labs refuse to build. Trust, not truth, is the scarce asset: provenance and positive human-attribution become priced layers once the Granta prize scandal supplies the consumer-grade catalyst. Detection stays a losing arms race; attestation that a human was load-bearing is the durable, unbuilt trade the AI companies keep leaving on the table.
Two RCTs from the same Wharton-adjacent research team flipped on a single design variable: roughly 1,000 Turkish high schoolers using ChatGPT-as-assistant underperformed AI-free controls at test time, while roughly 1,000 Taipei high schoolers using AI-as-tutor scored 0.15 SD higher on an AI-free final (roughly 6-9 months of additional schooling). Same AI, same population shape, opposite cognitive outcomes from problem-solver versus problem-poser configuration. The cognitive surrender debate has been miscast as a willpower problem; the actual lever sits at the procurement layer, currently owned by product managers optimizing engagement metrics rather than the L&D, HR, or operations leaders whose teams will live with the cognitive residue.
Stanford CS enrollment fell for the first time in 20 years over the past 18 months, the only hard data point in a Maureen Dowd op-ed otherwise stacked with five tech CEOs simultaneously elevating humanities. The Washington Post Texas study Dowd herself cites, liberal arts at the bottom of post-college payoff, points the opposite direction. Bilingual operators are the scarce profile (judgment plus AI fluency in the same graduate), and almost no credential currently produces them.
Gallup: 18-to-34-year-olds who say college is very important dropped from 74% in 2013 to 43% in 2019 to 35% in 2025, with the steepest fall landing before ChatGPT, which complicates Kang's AI-accelerates-disillusionment thesis. The sharper observation in his New Yorker piece is the one he undersells: when Galloway, Cowen, and Caplan all retreat to "it's just credentialing, but that still works," they've already abandoned the brief that justified higher education's claim on $700B a year in U.S. spending. The credential-only defense doesn't preserve the institution; it clarifies the terms of its decline.
